Prime 4 contains the familiar pieces of Metroid, but places them where they do the least good. Thin biomes, an overused desert, and a tedious crystal gate weaken an otherwise competent adventure with some excellent bosses.
Spoiler note: This review discusses the ending, companion outcomes, and final boss. Skip to the spoiler-free verdict.
THE RIGHT PIECES IN THE WRONG PLACES
Metroid Prime 4 is a weird game. It has different beams, upgrades, biomes, bosses, exploration, and backtracking. The familiar form of Metroid Prime is here.
The function of those features often feels misunderstood. It puts the right systems in the wrong places, creating an experience that is aggressively mediocre despite being recognizably competent.
I mostly had fun. The problem is how little the overall structure does with the pieces it has.
COMPANIONS COMPROMISE ISOLATION WITHOUT BUILDING ATTACHMENT
The NPCs are not as intrusive as some criticism suggests. Outside introductions and particular story moments, they are often absent.
That creates a different problem: they barely matter, so you barely care. Their occasional dialogue can still irritate, particularly Miles’ unsolicited hints.
When they sacrifice themselves at the end, the moment does not land because the campaign never builds a meaningful relationship between them and the player.
They are too present to preserve the feeling of isolation and too underdeveloped to create attachment.
SILENCE DOES NOT SOLVE SAMUS’ CHARACTERIZATION
Other M did not mishandle Samus simply because she talked. The problem was what she said and how she said it. Fusion demonstrated that an internal voice can work without damaging her character.
Here, NPCs talk at Samus and sometimes react as if she answered, while she remains completely silent. That creates an awkward presentation gap.
The game pushes character drama while refusing to acknowledge that Samus is also a character. Avoiding one past mistake produces a different one.
THE DESERT CARRIES THE WRONG BURDEN
Most of the classic exploration loop—gain an ability, return to earlier spaces, discover something new—is concentrated in the desert.
The shrines are decent puzzle rooms and often provide the most recognizably Metroid-like moments. The space between them is bland, open, and repetitive.
Driving over map hexes to find green crystals and shrines lacks the density and authored spatial design the series needs. Its most important exploration ends up in its least convincing exploration space.
THE CRYSTAL GATE TURNS DISCOVERY INTO GRINDING
The green crystal requirement is boring regardless of how it is framed. The original Metroid Prime had a flawed artifact hunt too, but this makes that problem considerably worse.
I knew about the requirement beforehand and deliberately gathered crystals as I played. The endgame still demanded multiple additional hours of farming.
Driving around the desert, hitting crystals, and clearing more shrines magnifies every weakness of that space.
A resource-gated ending is not inherently impossible to make work. Putting the resource in the dullest area and demanding hours of extra collection turns exploration into busywork.
THE BIOMES LOOK RIGHT AND FEEL TOO THIN
The individual biomes have strong atmosphere and visual identity. They look like places that belong in Metroid Prime.
As explorable spaces, they are too small, linear, and thin. Beyond a few easy upgrades, there is little reason to return. They feel more like themed levels than parts of an interconnected world.
The interesting areas are overly constrained, while the desert receives most of the exploration burden. Backtracking and discovery feel misplaced.
It gave me the impression of a world whose most promising regions were never developed enough to support the structure. That is an impression of the result, not knowledge of the development process.
THE BEAMS ARE MISSED OPPORTUNITIES
The different beams still function primarily as keys. Their combat roles are underdeveloped.
The electric beam felt like the strongest general option too often, while few enemies asked for interesting choices between beam types. For much of the campaign, I simply used the basic power beam.
Even the ice beam’s distinctive properties rarely received enough useful work. The arsenal looks familiar without creating much strategic texture.
THE BOSSES SHOW WHAT THE GAME CAN DO
The bosses range from decent to outright excellent. Sylux is not much of a character, but his final fight has genuine challenge, energy, and memorability.
These encounters show that the game can produce strong moments when it focuses. They cannot carry an entire structure that feels so unsure of where its best gameplay belongs.
Moment to moment, the game is playable and sometimes polished. It is also safe, thin, and underdeveloped enough to leave surprisingly little lasting impression.
VERDICT
Metroid Prime 4 is competent, playable, and sometimes enjoyable. On my scale, that does not make it secretly great.
The bosses and biome atmosphere are worthwhile. The underwritten companions, overused desert, crystal grind, thin regional spaces, and underutilized beams prevent the campaign from becoming memorable.
The shape of Metroid Prime survives. Too often, the structure fails to deliver the exploration and discovery that are supposed to make that shape meaningful.
7/10
Reviewed by VG Frogman
Platform: Nintendo Switch 2
Publication date: 10/10/2026

