How Frog Pit Gaming approaches criticism, reviews, and numerical scores.
PHILOSPHY
Frog Pit Gaming reviews games based primarily on how successfully their systems, mechanics, narrative, level design, progression, presentation, and other elements work together to create the experience the game is trying to provide.
A game does not need to reinvent its genre to be excellent. Innovation is not inherently quality, complexity is not inherently depth, and difficulty is not inherently meaningful. A familiar mechanic executed exceptionally well can contribute more to a game than an original idea that undermines the rest of the experience.
Reviews therefore focus heavily on interaction. What behavior does a system encourage? How does it interact with the game’s other systems? Does the friction it creates add something meaningful to the experience, or merely consume the player’s time? Does progression continue creating meaningful decisions once the player understands how the game works?
Games are evaluated as complete experiences whenever possible. A spectacular opening does not erase a weak final act, just as an initially awkward system may become meaningful once the rest of the design develops around it.
WHAT THE SCORE MEANS
The numerical score is a summary of the finished review, not a substitute for it.
Scores represent the overall quality of the experience after considering the game’s goals, execution, consistency, strengths, weaknesses, and the ways its individual elements interact.
Two games receiving the same score do not necessarily have the same strengths or weaknesses. Likewise, a technically ambitious game is not automatically scored higher than a simpler game that executes its ideas more successfully.
THE SCALE
Frog Pit Gaming does not use the conventional game-review scale where a 7/10 means “good.” An 8 is a good game. A 7 means the game is decent but meaningfully difficult to recommend. Scores below that represent increasingly fundamental design or functionality problems.
10 – SPECIAL
These are my current Game of the Year candidates. They are not necessarily perfect games, but they do something special within the medium or their genre. These are the games that stick with me, push an idea unusually far, or achieve something I consider exceptional. These will often be my most controversial ratings.
9 – AMAZING
Amazing games that I would recommend to almost anyone. They execute their premise with an exceptional level of competence, have a strong identity, and communicate that identity effectively through gameplay. Something is missing that keeps them from feeling truly special, but they are still exceptional games.
8 – GOOD
Good games with meaningful flaws in their execution that prevent them from becoming great. I would recommend them at full price to the right player, recommend most people wait for a sale, and tell some players to avoid them entirely depending on what those flaws are.
7 – DECENT
Decent games that become difficult to recommend outside of their existing genre audience. They are usually bland, forgettable, shallow, overly derivative, boring, or otherwise missing the compelling design necessary to rise above basic competence.
6 – POOR EXECUTION
Games I would recommend to almost nobody outside of people specifically interested in game design. These are often built around a genuinely good—or even great—idea that has been executed exceptionally poorly.
5 – SELF-INVALIDATING
Games with fundamentally interesting premises that are so poorly thought out that their own systems undermine the experience they were trying to create. These are difficult to recommend unless someone is intensely interested in the premise or can play them at a price low enough to reflect their quality—preferably free.
4 – FUNDAMENTALLY POOR
Games that are poorly conceived at a foundational level and do not have an interesting enough central premise to compensate. I would not recommend these games.
3 – BROKEN
Games that are literally broken or nonfunctional in a meaningful way. If the problems are fixed and I revisit the game, the score may change.
2 – MEME SCORE
Reserved for circumstances where the score itself is part of the joke.
1 – TROLL SCORE
Reserved for when I am very obviously not serious.
